Skip to main content

Exit WCAG Theme

Switch to Non-ADA Website

Accessibility Options

Select Text Sizes

Select Text Color

Website Accessibility Information Close Options
Close Menu
Noyes Law Office, P.C. Get back on the road to freedom!
  • Get Back On The Road To Freedom!
  • ~
  • Free No Obligation Consultation

Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies Rules for “Idiopathic” Falls and Workers’ Compensation

WorkInjury6

Workers’ compensation covers injuries that arise “out of and in the course of employment.” Let’s say you fall off a ladder while performing some maintenance work at your employer’s office. That would clearly be an injury arising out of and in the course of your employment, so your employer would owe you workers’ compensation benefits.

But what if you fall at work due to an epileptic seizure or some obscure or unknown cause that is not directly tied to your job? These are known as “idiopathic” injuries. And in many states, employees cannot collect workers’ compensation at all for such accidents.

Does the Hardness of a Restaurant Floor Pose an “Increased Risk” of Injury to Employees?

The Iowa Supreme Court, however, recently weighed in on the subject and reached a different conclusion. The petitioner in this case worked for the respondent’s fast food restaurant in Council Bluffs. One evening, about two hours into his shift, the petitioner “experienced a full-body seizure,” according to eyewitness accounts. The seizure caused the petitioner to fall, strike his head on the tile floor, and sustain a serious brain injury that required surgical intervention.

This was not the petitioner’s first seizure. He suffered them before and after the accident described above. Because these seizures were a “personal condition,” the deputy commissioner of the Iowa Workers’ Compensation Commission denied the petitioner’s request for workers’ compensation benefits. The deputy commissioner stated, point-blank, that idiopathic falls “are not compensable under Iowa law.” The commissioner, and later an Iowa district court, both affirmed the deputy commissioner’s position.

But the Supreme Court did not. The justices noted there was only one prior published case in Iowa regarding idiopathic falls and workers’ compensation, which the Supreme Court decided in 2000. In that case, the Court said there was an exception to the general rule that employees were not entitled to workers’ compensation for idiopathic falls. That exception is for situations where “a condition of his employment increased the risk of injury.”

In the present case, the Court said the deputy commissioner, the commissioner, and the district court all incorrectly asserted that “as a matter of law that idiopathic falls onto level floors are not compensable.” Yet this ignores the existence of the increased-risk exception. In fact, it was possible that the “condition of the floor” at the time of the petitioner’s accident might have created an increased risk of injury. But the “hardness” of the floor was a “factual matter, not a legal one,” for the workers’ compensation commissioner to consider.

Speak with an Iowa Workers’ Compensation Attorney Today

Workers’ compensation cases often turn on the specific facts surrounding an employee’s injury. That is why it is important to consult with a qualified Southeast Iowa workers’ compensation lawyer following an accident. An attorney can help make sure you have all of the facts before taking a claim to the Workers’ Compensation Commission. So if you need advice or assistance, contact the Noyes Law Office, P.C., at 641-472-3236 to schedule a free, no-obligation consultation today.

Resource:

scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=14534139754348693652

https://www.noyeslawoffice.com/can-i-have-multiple-employers-for-purposes-of-workers-compensation/

  • $1 Million
    Truck vs. auto case. Policy limits a 35 year old married mother of two killed.
  • $812 Thousand
    Rear-End Motor Vehicle Accident
  • $650 Thousand
    Settlement for spouse of deceased worker.
  • $575 Thousand
    Premises Liability Settlement
  • $500 Thousand
    Auto accident settlement with resulting post-concussive head complications (no wage loss).
  • $350 Thousand
    Injury from work with complications after surgery.
  • $300 Thousand
    Policy limits for 88 year old man rear ended.
  • $190 Thousand
    Read-End Accident with Tinitus Diagnosis.
  • $180 Thousand
    Slip and fall with a broken arm and torn rotator cuff.
  • $190 Thousand
    Bilateral carpal tunnel injury- $135,000 against the employer and $55,000 against the Second Injury Fund.
  • $185 Thousand
    Injured back.
  • $175 Thousand
    Broken leg of a 67 year old.
  • $160 Thousand
    Broken hip of 83 year old woman.
  • $155 Thousand
    Non-displaced fractured hip.
  • $100 Thousand
    Aggravation of degeneration disk disease.
  • Previous
  • Next

Get Back On The Road To Freedom!

Free No Obligation Consultation

Our Southeast Iowa personal injury, workers compensation and bankruptcy attorneys serve clients in Fairfield, Ottumwa, Mt. Pleasant, Iowa City, Knoxville, Oskaloosa, Fort Madison, Muscatine, Keosauqua, Birmingham, Centerville, Bloomfield, Keokuk, Sigourney, Richland, Burlington, Washington & Columbus Junction.

Skip footer and go back to main navigation